about archives categories discussion contact

« Ask Me Anything...I Dare You | Main | ...from the "Hungry i" »

Strange Movies in a Bar

Nate of Polytropos, a fellow I've only met once but whom I seem to have a number of things in common besides simply blogging, follows through on the "ask 3 questions" meme, and wants to know:

1. The one time I met you at that blog-get-together-breakfast, you said that you'd love the chance to write Ultimate Doctor Strange. What are some of your particular ideas as to how do you would do, what would make it fun, etc.?

The joy of the Marvel Ultimates line is not just the chance to update the characters to the modern day, such as having Peter Parker be a molecular biology student rather than a simple chemist, but to insert into the origins of the character the seeds of what becomes the defining moments of their characters. Not to take anything away from the creators of these characters and stories originally, but when they were original in the 1960s, they were working on the installment plan, like a soap opera (which was actually the thing that set Marvel apart from other comics of the time, in that the stories did actually have some continuity from issue to issue), and like soap operas, the writers didn't necessarily have an end in mind, but just that next episode. Even so, some of the titles of that time did a good job of maintaining a theme across the comics, but given the chance to do it all again, a good writer can really explore what makes that story special.

For me, the Stephen Strange character is indicative of the modern dichotomy--a character trained in science but fatally flawed (in the original, his alcoholism destroys his career because he can't do surgery with his increasingly poor dexterity), who seeks redemption through faith. Unlike the rest of us, he doesn't have to rely on faith for long, as he observes true power through the mystical arts. But that's where a modern story could investigate something more--what if Strange's power actually derives solely from his faith, and if he begins to question it, than his mastery of the mystic arts is lost? And what about all those people from his previous life? How do they feel about a fallen but at one time respected surgeon coming back from a trip to Asia and taking up residence as a snake-oil salesman in Greenwich Village?

That's not to mention some of the ancilliary characters like Dormammu, his nemesis, and Clea, Dormammu's daughter, who becomes Strange's lover, apprentice, and eventual successor. Dormammu, of course, is just a stand-in for the adversary, which reinforces the science-faith story, but what does it mean to love the daughter of the devil?

My problem is I'd probably spend too much time on the set-up of all this, exploring Strange's life before he climbs the mountain, and that might not sit well with those who look to comics for action and mystical art.

2. What it your favorite scene from a Kurosawa movie, and why?

Does it make me a worse person to have to admit that I don't recall ever having seen a Kurosawa movie? My film education is horrendously spotty, unfortunately, as I not only am a product of a small town without much of a cinema and parents who didn't get cable television until I had left the nest. By then, my habits had already been set, and I've always preferred to read a book than watch the screen. While we lived in Washington state, we were part of a film club that helped me catch up on some classics (including La Dolce Vita, a film or two by those French directors, and identifying for me what has become my favorite film genre, the screwball).

3. Are you a coffee shop type person, a bar type person, or neither? What about your personality do you think accounts for your preference?

A non-smoking bar type person, I think, which for some people is an oxymoron, as their concept of a bar is one where they can expound between puffs on that cigarette. If I were British, I'd be a pub type person for sure. For one, I like alcohol in all its forms much better than the distillations of the coffee bean. Two, I'm much more of a night owl than a morning person, and a bar in the light of morning is probably one of the saddest places to be.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.engel-cox.org/mt32/mt-tb.cgi/388

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Strange Movies in a Bar:

» Ask Me Anything: Answers from Polytropos
Only one reader has stepped up to participate in the Ask Me Anything blogmeme so far. That’s OK; I’m sure the throngs are right around the corner, right guys? Guys? Right? Anyway, these questions come from Ana. See also Glen’s... [Read More]

Comments

"My problem is I’d probably spend too much time on the set-up of all this, exploring Strange’s life before he climbs the mountain, and that might not sit well with those who look to comics for action and mystical art."

Either this is sarcasm or you haven't read anything by Brian Michael Bendis, the writer who is practically taking over Marvel. Based on the pace of Ultimate fantastic Four, you'd have plenty of time to develop that stuff.

Some of the Ultimates line sits very poorly with me--I really dislike the Ultimate version of the Avengers, which I think just has lots of wretched excess in it.

Dr. Strange, it seems to me, would suffer from the problem that even in the 1960s incarnation, he was possibly the most sophisticated and 'grown-up' of the characters of the early Marvel Universe. Not even a hint of teen-age angst, or even something as cliched as the millionare inventor Tony Stark. Instead, a self-absorbed, egotistical man who loses and then finds himself in mysticism. I agree that you could do some interesting things with how people would react to that person after he "found" himself, but in a way, the core premise is already rather "Ultimate" in spirit.

The tricky thing would also be to re-invent magic in the Ultimate version of the Marvel Universe. This would maybe be a platform for me to get at one of *my* obsessions: what would it mean to live in a universe where other dimensions, devils, angels, and possibly God were not just things to believe in that never manifested in the world, but which had an empirical tangibility? One might try to explain how Strange can believe in and know all these things and yet others do not or cannot--but unless you play with the very tired, very tedious "Maybe he's crazy and just imagining it all" trope, you more or less have to affirm that what he accesses through magic is real. The interesting question is then, "Why is it real?" and also "Why don't evil spirits/devils/etc. just destroy humanity outright? What rules govern their predation?"

I know what you're saying about the Avengers in the Ultimate line--some of the changes are more about being more MAX than about being more complex, adult, etc. I was also initially turned off in the Ultimate X-Men by the HBO-like sex and violence, but thought the book improved as they finally got into what is the nugget of the X-Men story, that of being different in a world that doesn't accept that.

Has there ever been a comic that really dealt well with spirituality? Plenty play with the tropes: (Gaiman's "Murder Mysteries" and Lucifer; Preacher to some extent, but talk about your wretched excess there; Kingdom Come?. It certainly doesn't seem to have handled amongst the superhero backdrop, whereas we've had good stories on drugs, child abuse, the nature of power, etc. The Dr. Strange character seems the closest one to actually look into the religon angle without stretching it out of shape.

Post a comment

Immediacy - Home